| School Name | Graduation Rate | Transfer-out Rate | Retention Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alderson Broaddus University Philippi, WV | 33% | - | 57% |
| Appalachian Bible College Mount Hope, WV | 58% | - | 76% |
| Bethany College Bethany, WV | 42% | - | 75% |
| Davis & Elkins College Elkins, WV | 48% | - | 71% |
| University of Charleston Charleston, WV | 41% | 32% | 71% |
| West Virginia Wesleyan College Buckhannon, WV | 53% | - | 67% |
| Wheeling University Wheeling, WV | 70% | 27% | 72% |
| Average | 49.29% | 29.50% | 69.86% |