| School Name | SAT Score | ACT Score | Acceptance Rate | Yield | Undergraduate Tuition & Fees | Total Population | Graduation Rate | Students to Faculty Ratio | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 - | University of Notre Dame Notre Dame, IN Private, four-years | 1,510 30 | 34 | 12.91% | 59.54% | $62,693 | 13,105 | 96.00% | 9 to 1 |
| 2 4 | Holy Cross College Notre Dame, IN Private, four-years | 1,320 105 | - | 76.17% | 28.23% | $35,500 | 434 | 32.00% | 10 to 1 |
| 3 2 | Earlham College Richmond, IN Private, four-years | 1,270 50 | 26 | 73.24% | 17.08% | $51,840 | 677 | 74.00% | 6 to 1 |
| 4 2 | DePauw University Greencastle, IN Private, four-years | 1,250 40 | 28 | 65.80% | 14.24% | $57,070 | 1,752 | 79.00% | 9 to 1 |
| 5 | Valparaiso University Valparaiso, IN Private, four-years | 1,240 | 28 | 94.15% | 9.38% | $46,588 | 2,958 | 69.00% | 11 to 1 |
| 6 3 | Butler University Indianapolis, IN Private, four-years | 1,230 15 | 28 | 82.06% | 10.92% | $45,980 | 5,525 | 80.00% | 11 to 1 |
| 7 3 | Wabash College Crawfordsville, IN Private, four-years | 1,225 15 | 26 | 61.49% | 21.92% | $49,125 | 835 | 75.00% | 9 to 1 |
| 8 - | Saint Mary's College Notre Dame, IN Private, four-years | 1,220 60 | 28 | 83.89% | 20.94% | $51,430 | 1,519 | 74.00% | 9 to 1 |
| 9 2 | Hanover College Hanover, IN Private, four-years | 1,190 20 | 26 | 74.11% | 11.85% | $42,894 | 1,124 | 69.00% | 11 to 1 |
| 10 1 | University of Evansville Evansville, IN Private, four-years | 1,160 10 | 25 | 76.32% | 11.23% | $42,676 | 2,017 | 64.00% | 10 to 1 |
| Average | 1,262 | 28 | 70.01% | 20.53% | $48,580 | 2,995 | 71.20% | 10 to 1 |
