| School Name | 2018-19 | 2019-20 | 2020-21 | 2021-22 | 2022-23 | 5-Year Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alderson Broaddus UniversityPhilippi, WV | 42.53% | 47.13% 4.6% | 52.76% 5.64% | 66.53% 13.77% | 61.49% 5.04% | 18.96% |
| Appalachian Bible CollegeMount Hope, WV | 45.24% | 37.06% 8.18% | 48.74% 11.68% | 46.15% 2.59% | 100.00% 53.85% | 54.76% |
| Bethany CollegeBethany, WV | 90.77% | 95.30% 4.54% | 91.84% 3.47% | 73.55% 18.28% | 64.92% 8.63% | 25.85% |
| University of CharlestonCharleston, WV | 50.42% | 50.04% 0.38% | 61.48% 11.43% | 69.71% 8.23% | 67.73% 1.98% | 17.31% |
| Davis & Elkins CollegeElkins, WV | 36.95% | 39.80% 2.85% | 69.05% 29.25% | 77.61% 8.56% | 75.26% 2.35% | 38.31% |
| West Virginia Wesleyan CollegeBuckhannon, WV | 70.17% | 64.15% 6.03% | 65.72% 1.57% | 84.43% 18.71% | 96.35% 11.93% | 26.18% |
| Wheeling UniversityWheeling, WV | 86.34% | 68.25% 18.09% | 76.82% 8.57% | 78.07% 1.25% | 72.65% 5.42% | 13.69% |
| Average | 60.35% | 57.39% 2.95% | 66.63% 9.24% | 70.87% 4.24% | 76.91% 6.05% | 16.57% |